Smokeball vs MyCase: Which Is Better for Small Firms?
TLDR
Smokeball has stronger document automation and automatic time capture, but requires a 3-year contract and only works with Outlook. MyCase is more affordable, has no long-term commitment, and includes a client portal on every plan — but its document tools are consistently rated poor by users. For small firms that want month-to-month terms, IOLTA included, and no Outlook requirement, CaelusLaw is worth evaluating at $20/user/month (Essentials).
| Feature | Smokeball | MyCase | CaelusLaw |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost (small team) | $39-219/user/mo | $39-99/user/mo | From $20/user/mo |
| Setup fee | Varies | Varies | $0 |
| Contract | 3-year contract | Monthly available | Month-to-month |
| IOLTA trust accounting | Add-on or higher tier | Add-on or higher tier | Included |
Smokeball vs MyCase at a Glance
Smokeball and MyCase serve overlapping audiences — small law firms that want more than a spreadsheet but less than an enterprise platform. The surface-level similarity masks a real choice between two different bets.
Smokeball is built around automatic time capture and document automation. MyCase is built around affordability, client communication, and ease of use. The contract terms make the decision sharper: MyCase lets you leave any month, Smokeball binds you for three years.
Pricing Comparison
As of March 2026:
Smokeball: Bill $39/user/mo, Boost $89/user/mo (trust accounting included), Grow $179/user/mo, Prosper+ $219/user/mo. All plans require a 3-year contract. Renewal pricing is at Smokeball’s discretion.
MyCase: Basic $39/user/mo (no trust accounting), Pro $79/user/mo (trust accounting included), Advanced $99/user/mo. Month-to-month billing standard.
For a 5-attorney firm needing trust accounting: Smokeball Boost costs $445/month locked in for 36 months. MyCase Pro costs $395/month with no commitment. That’s $600/year cheaper on MyCase — and you can leave if it isn’t working.
Key Differences
Contract terms: Smokeball’s 3-year contract is the defining constraint. The contract has no early-exit refund provision — prepaid amounts are not returned if you leave before the term ends. MyCase has no such requirement. For a small firm, this matters — practices change, rosters shrink, and software that seemed right in year one may not fit in year three.
Automatic time capture: Smokeball tracks billable activity automatically in the background. For attorneys who consistently under-record time, this feature alone can recover more than the software’s monthly cost. MyCase requires manual time entry — attorneys have to remember to run a timer or log time after the fact.
Document automation: Smokeball’s document assembly is the strongest in its price range. Pre-filled legal forms, template libraries, and practice-area-specific packages reduce drafting time for volume work. MyCase’s document tools are described by users as limited and unreliable for actual drafting.
Email integration: MyCase works with Gmail and Outlook. Smokeball is Outlook-only. Firms on Google Workspace cannot use Smokeball’s email sync at all.
Trust accounting: Both include IOLTA at mid-tier plans. MyCase requires the Pro plan ($79/user/mo). Smokeball includes it from the Boost plan ($89/user/mo). Pricing is comparable on this point, though Smokeball requires the 3-year commitment to access it.
What About CaelusLaw?
Smokeball’s automatic time capture is genuinely useful — but the 3-year contract is a hard ask for a small firm betting on software it hasn’t proven out yet. MyCase’s document tools are consistently criticized, and trust accounting requires upgrading past the base tier.
CaelusLaw is built for firms with 1-20 attorneys. IOLTA trust accounting is included at every tier, starting with Essentials ($20/user/month) — no separate tier required. Works with both Gmail and Outlook. Month-to-month only. If you want trust accounting without a three-year commitment or a product fragmentation problem, CaelusLaw is worth a look.
| Feature | Smokeball | MyCase |
|---|---|---|
| Starting price | $39/user/mo (Bill, limited) | $39/user/mo (Basic) |
| Trust accounting (IOLTA) | Boost tier+ ($89/user/mo) | Pro tier+ ($79/user/mo) |
| Document automation | Best-in-class, included | Poor — not a drafting tool |
| Automatic time capture | Yes | No — manual entry |
| Email integration | Outlook only | Gmail and Outlook |
| Client portal | Included | Included at all tiers |
| Contract required | Yes — 3-year contract | No (monthly standard) |
| Best for | Document-heavy practices with Outlook | Affordability, no lock-in, client communication |
PROS & CONS
Smokeball
Pros
- Automatic time capture logs billable work without manual timers
- Best document automation in the category — pre-filled forms, templates, assembly
- Practice-area specialization for real estate, family law, and litigation
- Outlook integration is deep and reliable for those already on Microsoft 365
Cons
- 3-year contract with auto-renewal and no early exit refunds
- No Gmail integration — Outlook only
- Renewal pricing is not locked by the original contract
- Higher price at mid and upper tiers ($89-219/user/mo)
PROS & CONS
MyCase
Pros
- Month-to-month billing — no multi-year lock-in
- Client portal included in every plan including the $39 Basic tier
- Affordable entry point for solo attorneys and small teams
- Good mobile app for time entry and client communication
Cons
- No trust accounting on the Basic plan — requires Pro ($79/user/mo)
- Document drafting tools consistently rated poor in user reviews
- No conflict check in intake workflow
- Limited invoice customization for complex billing structures
Is Smokeball worth the premium and 3-year contract over MyCase?
For practice areas that generate high document volume — real estate closings, family law, estate planning — Smokeball's automatic time capture and document assembly can reduce write-offs and save hours per week. That value case exists. For general practice or advisory-heavy firms where billing is the primary need, the 3-year commitment and Outlook dependency are hard to justify when MyCase or similar tools are available month-to-month at lower cost.
Does Smokeball automatically track billable time compared to MyCase?
Yes. Smokeball's automatic time capture records work activity in the background — document edits, emails, phone calls — without requiring attorneys to run a timer. MyCase requires manual time entry. For attorneys who consistently under-record billable time, this is the single biggest practical difference between the two platforms.
Source: MyCase pricing page (March 2026)
Verdict
MyCase wins on price, flexibility, and contract terms. Smokeball wins on document automation and time capture. For firms that live in document-heavy practice areas like real estate or estate planning, Smokeball's features may justify the 3-year commitment. For everyone else, MyCase's lack of lock-in and lower cost is harder to argue against. CaelusLaw ($20/user/month, Essentials) includes IOLTA, works with Gmail and Outlook, and has no multi-year contracts.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Smokeball require a long-term contract while MyCase doesn't?
Does MyCase include trust accounting?
Does Smokeball work with Gmail?
Which is cheaper — Smokeball or MyCase?
Ready to simplify your practice?
Reserve Your SpotNo credit card required. No annual contract.
Related Comparisons
Best Smokeball Alternative for Small Law Firms
Looking for a Smokeball alternative? CaelusLaw has no multi-year contracts, works with Gmail and Outlook, and includes IOLTA trust accounting — starting at $20/user/mo.
Best MyCase Alternative for Small Law Firms
Looking for a MyCase alternative? CaelusLaw offers better invoicing, multi-case handling, and IOLTA trust accounting included — starting at $20/user/mo.
Smokeball Pricing Breakdown (2026): What It Really Costs
What does Smokeball actually cost for a small law firm? We break down per-user pricing, 3-year contracts, price increases, and hidden costs across all tiers.
How to Choose Legal Practice Management Software for Your Small Firm
A step-by-step guide for small law firm partners evaluating practice management software. Covers must-have features, IOLTA compliance, pricing models, and migration planning.